For most businesses with revenue up to about $50 million, a virtual CFO is the better choice until three things are true at once: there is a full week of CFO work every week, there is a team for a CFO to lead, and the business needs that person in the building every day. Until then, a full-time hire tends to cost more than it returns, and the person you hire often ends up doing work well below the role.
This article is about that decision. If you want the price of a virtual CFO, our virtual CFO cost guide covers the fee and what moves it, and our article on virtual, fractional and outsourced CFOs explains the names.
The real question is how much CFO work there is
Most businesses that ask this question are really asking whether they need a CFO’s judgement every day, or only at certain moments. In a growing business the work tends to come in waves: a budget each year, a bank review, a refinance, a new site, a sale process. Between those, the monthly rhythm of reports, a review meeting and an updated forecast takes a few days a month.
A full-time CFO earns their place when that changes, and the work becomes constant. In larger businesses a CFO’s week fills up with things like these:
Leading a finance team
Several people in accounts, payroll and reporting who need managing, developing and reviewing every day.
A monthly board cycle
Board papers, committee meetings and directors who expect the CFO in the room each time.
Lenders on a short leash
Covenant reporting, frequent bank contact and facilities that need managing actively.
A run of transactions
Acquisitions one after another, or a long capital raising or listing process.
Large systems projects
Replacing the accounting or operational systems across a group, which takes months of daily attention.
If most of that list describes your business today, a full-time CFO is probably close. If it describes one or two weeks a year, a virtual CFO who steps up for those weeks will usually serve you better.
What a full-time CFO brings
There are real advantages to a CFO of your own, and it helps to name them plainly.
Presence
They are in the corridor when an operational decision is being made, and can weigh in before it is made.
Depth
Over time they learn the business in detail: every customer contract, every supplier, the history behind each number.
Leadership
They manage the finance team day to day and set its standards.
Availability
They are there on any day, for any question, including the small ones nobody would book a meeting for.
What a virtual CFO brings
Breadth
A virtual CFO sees many businesses at once, so they have usually met your problem before, in another industry or at another stage.
A team already in place
Through our Finance Hub the CFO comes with an outsourced finance team doing the monthly work, so there is nobody else to hire.
Speed
Where the books are clean, we can usually start within two to four weeks of a first meeting. Recruiting a senior finance leader typically takes much longer.
Room to flex
More time around a refinance or acquisition, less in a quiet quarter, without renegotiating anybody’s employment.
Continuity
Leave, illness and resignations are the firm’s problem to cover, and the knowledge of your business sits with a team rather than one person.
The cost of hiring too early, and too late
The most common mistake we see is a business hiring a full-time CFO before there is a finance team underneath them. A senior person arrives, finds the books behind and the month-end unreliable, and spends their first year reconciling accounts and chasing invoices. The business pays a CFO’s salary for controller work, and the strategic work it hired them for waits.
Hiring too late has a cost as well, though it is harder to see. Decisions about a new site, a large contract or a loan get made on instinct, and the business only finds out what they cost when the year-end accounts arrive. A virtual CFO is often the way to close that gap early without the risk of a senior hire.
Five tests before you hire
If you answer yes to most of these, it is time to start planning a full-time CFO.
Is there a full week of CFO work, every week?
Count the hours a CFO would genuinely spend each week over a year, quiet months included.
Is there a team for them to lead?
A CFO with nobody reporting to them will drift into doing the team’s work.
Do your lenders or investors expect one on staff?
Some later-stage investors and larger facilities do. Most banks lending to a private business care more about reliable reporting.
Is a long transaction coming?
A listing, a sustained acquisition program or a major capital raise can justify the role on its own.
Could you attract and keep the right person?
A strong CFO wants a role with scope. If the job is mostly reporting and review, the right person may not stay.
The middle path most growing businesses take
Many businesses between these two points do best with a mix: their own finance manager or bookkeeper in the building, and a virtual CFO working above them. The in-house person knows the suppliers, answers the everyday questions and keeps the records moving. The virtual CFO reviews what they produce, designs the reporting and leads the decisions. Our article on when to hire a finance manager covers the first half of that arrangement in detail.
That mix also gives the business an easy way to grow into a full-time CFO later, because the structure is already there.
Look at the next three years, not just this one
The choice often depends more on where the business is heading than where it is today.
A sale or succession ahead
Buyers pay closer attention to a business with reliable monthly reporting, clean forecasts and a clear history behind the numbers. A virtual CFO can build that over the years before a sale, without adding a senior salary the buyer may not want to keep.
A run of acquisitions
Each acquisition brings a new entity, new systems and new people. If several are planned, a CFO of your own may be worth hiring ahead of the first, so the integration work has an owner.
A family business passing to the next generation
A virtual CFO can give the incoming generation a shared, independent view of the numbers, which often helps more than a new employee reporting to one side of the family.
Steady, profitable growth
Where the plan is more of the same, done well, the monthly rhythm of a virtual CFO usually stays the right fit for a long time.
Making the switch when the time comes
When a business does outgrow a virtual CFO, the change works best as a planned handover.
Write the role from the work
The virtual CFO already knows what the job involves, so the role description comes from the real work of the past year.
Recruit with help
The virtual CFO can help shortlist and interview, and test candidates against the business’s actual reporting and decisions.
Overlap the two
A few months where both work together lets the new CFO learn the history behind each number.
Keep what works
The reporting, forecasts and governance carry on, and the outsourced team can keep running underneath until an in-house team is built.
Virtual and full-time CFOs, frequently asked questions
When should a business hire a full-time CFO?
Prime Partners’ view is that a business is ready for a full-time CFO when there is a full week of CFO-level work every week, a finance team for the CFO to lead, and a real need for that person to be in the business every day. Before that point, a virtual CFO usually gives the same judgement at a fraction of the cost.
Can a virtual CFO be as effective as a full-time CFO?
For most growing businesses, yes. A virtual CFO gives the same strategic work, reporting, forecasting and decision modelling, for the share of the month the business actually needs it. A full-time CFO becomes more effective when the work is constant and there is a team to lead every day.
Can a virtual CFO help us recruit a full-time CFO?
Yes. A virtual CFO who already knows the business can write the role from the real work, help shortlist and interview candidates, and overlap with the new CFO for a handover period so the reporting and forecasts carry on without a gap.
Do banks require a business to have a full-time CFO?
Most banks lending to a private business care more about reliable reporting and realistic forecasts than about who prepares them. Some larger facilities and later-stage investors do expect a CFO on staff, so it is worth asking your lender directly.
Talk to us
If you are weighing up a full-time hire, get in touch. Greg Dennis runs our Finance Hub, and a first conversation about how much CFO work your business really has is a good place to start.
How we can helpVirtual CFO and finance team Monthly management accounts, cash flow forecasting and a senior finance view, without the cost of a full time CFO.





