Skip to content
Prime Partners, Chartered Accountants
Articles and insights

Back-to-Back CGT Rollovers: Why the Extra Company?

When Beth put her retail business into a company, she had a growing shop to run. A buyer approached her six months later. When Mary set up her company, she and her sisters had already agreed to merge their businesses.

The ATO chose these two owners to illustrate its draft guideline on back-to-back capital gains tax (CGT) rollovers. They used the same two rollovers. Why would the ATO give Mary’s transaction a closer look?

What did the new company do for the business?

Beth was a sole trader. She transferred her business assets to a company she owned so she could manage the growth of her retail business. She received shares in exchange and used the rollover in Subdivision 122-A to defer the capital gain on the transfer. She intended to keep trading.

Six months later, another business owner approached her. During negotiations they decided to merge, and Beth exchanged her shares for shares in his company. That exchange qualified for a second rollover, known as scrip-for-scrip relief under Subdivision 124-M. The new shares kept substantially the same tax cost as her old ones. When Beth eventually sold them, she made a capital gain. The ATO puts Beth in its lower-risk category. Incorporating made commercial sense even if the buyer had never called.

Mary and her sisters already owned a company together. They wanted to bring Mary’s sole trader business into it and share ownership. On the facts in the draft, transferring her business assets straight to the sisters’ company would have triggered a capital gain. Instead, Mary transferred the assets to a new company she owned outright. The sisters’ company then acquired her shares in that company in exchange for more shares in the family company.

The family had a good reason to merge. The difficulty for Mary was explaining why the merger needed another company. In the ATO’s example, its only job was to give Mary shares she could exchange under the second rollover. That extra step deferred the gain she would otherwise have made, which puts Mary in the ATO’s higher-risk category. Waiting six months between the steps would leave that question unanswered. ATO draft guideline, examples 1 and 2

When will the ATO take a closer look?

The draft covers successive CGT events affecting the same asset or its replacement, where the taxpayer chooses rollover relief for at least two of those events. A restructure can involve several transfers and still fall outside the guideline if only one rollover is chosen.

The ATO looks more closely where the steps depend on one another, an intermediate step does little beyond making a further rollover available, and the sequence produces a particular tax advantage. Deferring a gain, as Mary did, is one example. Others include preserving an asset’s pre-CGT status when a direct transfer would lose it, lifting the tax cost of an asset so a future gain is smaller or a loss larger, or increasing depreciation deductions. Ordinary market movements are excluded when comparing future gains or losses.

A higher-risk assessment tells you the ATO is more likely to review the transaction. An ATO review can examine both eligibility for each rollover and the separate question of whether Part IVA, the general anti-avoidance rule, applies. Under Part IVA, the Commissioner can cancel a tax benefit if the objective facts support the conclusion that someone entered into or carried out the scheme, or part of it, for the dominant purpose of securing that benefit for a taxpayer.

We’ve already restructured. What should we pull out of the file?

Start with the first proposal that went to the owners. Put it beside the first email from the buyer, investor or bank. Had the parties already agreed on the second transaction when they approved the first? The dates on those two documents may tell you more than the signed minutes.

Then look for the alternatives the owners considered. If the minutes say a lender required a separate company, find the lender’s letter and check which entity it wanted to hold which assets. If the owners considered a direct transfer, keep the advice or calculations showing what that route would have cost and why they chose a different one. If the valuation or an early draft of the agreement is missing, the solicitor who worked on the deal may still have a copy.

If you’re planning a restructure ahead of the 2027 tax changes, ask your adviser to draw the proposed steps alongside the most direct way of getting the assets to their intended owner. Compare the tax under each route. For every extra company or transfer, write down what the business gains by including it. If you’d like us to work through it with you, bring the group structure diagram and the proposed sequence of transfers. Business structure reviews at Prime Partners

Back-to-back CGT rollovers, frequently asked questions

Written by: James Carey, DirectorSource: Australian Taxation Office

What is a back-to-back CGT rollover?

Under the ATO’s draft guideline, it’s when two or more CGT events happen in succession involving the same asset or its replacement, and rollover relief is chosen for at least two of those events. One example is transferring business assets to a company in exchange for shares, then exchanging those shares for shares in another company as part of a merger. ATO draft guideline PCG 2026/D5

Can I use two CGT rollovers in the same restructure?

Yes, if each rollover’s eligibility requirements are met. Under its draft guideline, the ATO is more likely to review a restructure where the steps depend on each other and an extra step serves little commercial purpose beyond securing a tax advantage. For example, the owners may have a sound reason to merge their businesses. The ATO may still ask why they needed to set up another company to do it. ATO draft guideline PCG 2026/D5

How long should I wait between CGT rollovers?

The ATO’s draft gives no minimum waiting period. In the ATO’s lower-risk example, a buyer approached the owner six months after she incorporated. What mattered was that she had set up the company to manage her growing business. The idea of a merger came later, during negotiations with the buyer. Simply leaving six months between two steps that were planned together would leave the same question about why both were needed. ATO draft guideline, example 1

If the ATO considers my restructure higher risk, will I have to pay CGT?

A higher-risk assessment means the ATO is more likely to review the transaction. During a review, it can check whether you met the conditions for each rollover and consider whether Part IVA, the general anti-avoidance rule, applies. Any additional tax depends on the facts of your restructure. ATO draft guideline PCG 2026/D5

We’ve already restructured. What records should we keep?

The ATO proposes to apply the final guideline to earlier arrangements as well as future ones. Keep the documents that show what the owners knew when they approved each step. A proposal explaining why you incorporated, the first email from a potential buyer or a lender’s written requirement for a separate company can help establish the sequence. If you considered a direct transfer, keep the advice showing why you chose a different route.

The ATO released draft PCG 2026/D5 on 11 November 2026. It proposes to apply the final guideline to arrangements entered into before and after its issue. Submissions close on 11 December 2026. ATO consultation details and status

How we can helpBusiness structure review Whether your company, trust or partnership still suits the business you run now, and what a change would involve.
James Carey
Written by

James Carey

Director

More about James
Prime Insights

Clear thinking on the decisions that matter.

Once a month we send our latest thinking on tax, business, and the moments that shape a year. Practical, considered, and written for people who would rather understand the why than chase the headline.

Stay in the loop

Some of the biggest calls in a business and a life land between the appointments and the deadlines. Following along keeps you close to how we think, so when one of those moments turns up, you already know where to find us.

Trusted and accredited
★★★★★4.8 on Google from 70+ reviewsEstablished 2006, 20 years in business
CPA AustraliaChartered Accountants ANZXero Platinum Partner